Localeze + Bing versus Google + Yelp
I noticed an article from MediaPost this morning that talks about Microsoft signing a deeper relationship with Localeze recently for use in Bing’s local efforts. This is one of those fly under the radar types of news items that garners very little attention, unlike say the big fuss made over the potential Google – Yelp acquisition. It’s just another day to day type deal, so I suppose there is no reason for it to grab headlines but in my mind this type of deal between Microsoft and Localeze is much more interesting than Google and Yelp.
I love Yelp and use it frequently, and to a degree I get the rationale on why its a potentially attractive acquisition, particularly for someone like Google that is looking so aggressively at targeting the local brick and mortar businesses, and their advertising budget. Yelp has many of the right relationships with local advertisers and at the same time has a nice content creation tool and user base who rabidly create tons of local oriented content… all a very nice fit with what Google does and where they’re looking to grow.
But the deal between Microsoft and Localeze in my mind directly tries to fix something that is currently wrong when you search for local businesses. So many times I try to fire up a mobile browser in the hopes of searching for things around me, and so many times the experience is just so damn underwhelming. No sign of businesses that have existed for years and years, no understanding that I am a consumer looking to walk into a retailer and dont care if someone deep in the skyscraper in front of me runs a web LLC out of their apartment on the 25th floor.
I can still stand on the sidewalk peering into the window outside of Sohpie’s Cuban Cuisine staring at huge baskets filled with yummy empanadas and then turn and do a mobile search for the term ‘empanadas’ and end up being directed to go miles away to Empanada Joe’s, Empanada Mama’s, and Reuben’s Empanadas.
Currently the local search solutions are either far too simplistic in understanding the search query… ie search for ‘empanadas’ and get back a list of places with ‘empanada’ in their business names, or they return 372,000 page that match the place and the term ‘empanada’ which is an unwieldy mess to sort through if you’re just standing on the corner with 15 minutes of your lunch break left.
Localeze clearly has this problem in their sights and is looking to help connect mobile searchers with the closest place to fill their bellys with empanadas even if the place selling you those empandas is called Sophies.
For Google at least, there may be a day when all of those Yelpers will rave about the great empanadas at Sophies and the Google algorithm would put aside those 371k other pages, and put two and two together and match the Yelp content about empanadas at Sophies with the Sophie’s business listing and give me a great search result. But the problem for Google may be that it’s special sauce is built around links (and votes) between web pages not necessarily analyzing the content or intent of the words within pages… so whether or not Google can effectively and reliably make that connection, particularly without owning the content is still a big TBD.
